Bad news for YouTube creators who depend on Patreon

YouTube is denying some creators the ability to embed links to outside sites.
By
Patrick Kulp
 on 
Bad news for YouTube creators who depend on Patreon
YouTube is cracking down on Patreon links. Credit: Dan R. Krauss/Getty Images

YouTube's sometimes uneven crackdown on ads placed on offensive content has driven some video creators to the crowd-funding site Patreon for a more reliable source of income.

But that alternative may become a bit more difficult after an update the Google-owned site rolled out this week.

Google no longer lets creators who aren't part of its partnership program embed links to external sites like Patreon within their videos.

The change is supposed to "curb abuse" by encouraging channel owners to partner with the site so it can "evaluate the validity of the channel" and determine whether the videos are appropriate, a Google spokesperson said.

YouTube creators do not necessarily have to run ads on their videos to qualify for the linking privilege, but their content does have to fall within the site's conduct rules. Non-partner users are also still allowed to link to outside sites in the video description, though that placement is much less prominent to viewers.

Google says it rolled out the update because its automated system detected that some of these link screens were being used in ways it considered harmful to users.

Mashable Light Speed
Want more out-of-this world tech, space and science stories?
Sign up for Mashable's weekly Light Speed newsletter.
By clicking Sign Me Up, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up!

The company has taken a much stricter stance on policing videos since advertisers revolted en masse over placements on videos from Nazi groups, terrorists, and other hate-mongers earlier this year.

But some creators claim the measures--most of which are handled through algorithms and automated systems--have been applied arbitrarily and that YouTube hasn't exactly been transparent or responsive about why some videos are demonetized but others are not.

A YouTube user who goes by the pseudonym Russell said ads for his 4.8-million-subscriber channel, "Ownage Pranks," have become more unreliable in recent months. When he tries to contact YouTube about the issue, administrators aren't often forthcoming with the reasoning behind the demonetization.

"I have a huge loyalty to YouTube--it's why my channel flourished," Russell said. "But Patreon and other ways to supplement income are crucial, especially when there's just no guarantees with what YouTube is going to do. They could just flip the switch on you at any time."

Russell said he expects to depend more on his own Patreon and other diversified income streams like mobile apps going forward.

Topics Google YouTube

Mashable Image
Patrick Kulp

Patrick Kulp is a Business Reporter at Mashable. Patrick covers digital advertising, online retail and the future of work. A graduate of UC Santa Barbara with a degree in political science and economics, he previously worked at the Pacific Coast Business Times.


Recommended For You
YouTube is changing what a 'view' means for YouTube Shorts
YouTube Shorts logo

Best movies by women creators on Netflix
Composite of movies on Netflix, directed by women.


The 21 best TV shows by Black creators on Netflix
Scenes from "Insecure," "Colin in Black & White," "Bridgerton," and "Champion."

'Talk to Me' creators return with 'Bring Her Back' trailer
A cat in a hall.

More in Tech

Earn double points on Kindle book purchases on April 8
Three book covers on a colorful background

All the best e-book deals to shop at Amazon, Kobo, and Bookshop.org
A colorful background with three book covers on it

Five years of remote work changed workplace accessibility. Employees with disabilities will feel its loss.
An illustration of a fist smashing down on a computer "return" key, with small ADA symbols and houses ricocheting off from the impact.

Get on the water for under $70: This Kayak set is only $69.99 at Woot
A top-down view of an inflatable kayak set laid out on a light background with subtle blue watercolor-like accents.

Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for April 8, 2025
Connections game on a smartphone

NYT Strands hints, answers for April 8
A game being played on a smartphone.


Wordle today: Answer, hints for April 8, 2025
Wordle game on a smartphone

How to watch Arsenal vs. Real Madrid online for free
Jude Bellingham of Real Madrid celebrates
The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
These newsletters may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. By clicking Subscribe, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!